UTCSW Faculty Member Dr. Shelby McDonald Lends Her Expertise Regarding Human-Animal Interaction During Pregnancy

Dr. Shelby McDonald

UTCSW Faculty Member and Director of the Center for Veterinary Social Work Dr. Shelby McDonald recently shared her expertise with The Guardian in an article regarding the changes in relationships with animals during pregnancy.  

The article titled “12 weeks and SO disgusted by my dog: what happens when you’re pregnant and can’t stand your pet?” explores changes in relationships with companion animals during pregnancy and the postpartum period.  The article discusses research showing that the transition to parenthood can affect human-animal relationships, including changes in the time and attention available for companion animals, feelings of closeness, caregiving capacity, and, for some families, decisions about rehoming.

McDonald is quoted acknowledging that “the postpartum period can be a vulnerable time for the human-animal bond” and that “new families with pets face challenges including the safety of their baby around a rambunctious dog, and irritation due to barking, shedding and the click-clack of canine nails.”  She points out that “a family’s capacity to meet an animal’s needs may change substantially, whether physically, emotionally, practically or financially.”

Currently collaborating on a study with the University of Edinburgh involving in-depth interviews with mothers in the UK about their experiences with companion animals during pregnancy and postpartum, McDonald noted that research with new parents has documented reductions in time and attention devoted to pets, and, for some people, changes in feelings of closeness to their animals. “A parent can remain deeply attached to an animal while temporarily having much less capacity to care for or interact with them in the way they did before the baby arrived,” she said.

McDonald recognizes that there can be “tremendous shame” associated with relinquishing or rehoming an animal,  but states that it is important for new parents to notice when normal frustration and caregiver fatigue cross into the territory of abuse or neglect, which she describes as an animal being denied adequate food and water, opportunities for exercise and elimination, a reasonably clean and safe environment, veterinary care or social interaction. “Recognizing that an animal’s welfare and wellbeing is being compromised and making a thoughtful plan for their care can itself be an act of responsible caregiving,” she said. “The priority should be the wellbeing and safety of both the person and the animal, rather than preserving a particular living arrangement at all costs.”

Click here to read the full article in The Guardian.